Building a good reputation and top tips for success as an expert witness

Building a good reputation and top tips for success as an expert witness
The final article in a short series written by Emma Bracher, Care and OT Expert and Associate of Maggie Sargent & Associates.
Building a good reputation
Building a good professional reputation is important in expert witness work. It can lead to repeat instructions, but working with solicitors and barristers you already know can also make the whole process much easier and more efficient.
Over time, you get to understand how they work, their expectations and how they like to communicate. Equally, they get to know you and the standard of work you provide. This familiarity can make a real difference when you're juggling expert witness work alongside your clinical commitments.
The majority of my cases now come from solicitors and barristers I have worked with previously, and these relationships have been invaluable. Barristers can also recommend experts to solicitors, so a good reputation can open doors to further opportunities.
So, what helps build that reputation?
- Be approachable - Make it easy for solicitors and barristers to contact you. Don't be afraid to pick up the phone or ask questions. I know speaking to solicitors can feel intimidating when you're new to the field, but remember, they're people too! A quick conversation can often resolve something that might otherwise involve several emails.
- Be reliable and realistic -Submit reports on time, meet agreed deadlines and be honest about your availability. If you anticipate a delay, let the instructing solicitor know as early as possible. It's much better to agree a realistic timescale than promise something you can't deliver.
- Be professional and independent - Your duty is to the court. Be polite and helpful, but never allow the desire to please an instructing solicitor or barrister to influence your opinion. A good solicitor or barrister will respect your independence and should not expect you to change your professional opinion to support their client's case. Your role is to provide an honest, objective and impartial opinion, not to advocate for either side.
- Produce high-quality work - Aim for clear, well-structured reports, pay attention to detail and ensure your opinions and recommendations are supported by the evidence. Consistency and quality will help build confidence in your work.
- Communicate well - Respond to queries promptly and keep solicitors updated on progress. If something is unclear, ask for clarification rather than making assumptions.
Ultimately, people appreciate experts who are knowledgeable, reliable and pleasant to work with. Your reputation will grow through the quality of your work and how you conduct yourself.
Top Tips for Success as an Expert Witness
If I could offer a few final pieces of advice to anyone starting out in expert witness work, they would be these:
- Know your expertise
Be clear about your knowledge, skills and experience. Don't take on instructions outside your area of competence, and remember that knowing when to say no is just as important as knowing when to say yes. - Be organised and manage your time
Allow plenty of time for reviewing records, assessments, report writing and follow-up work. Develop your own assessment and report templates (unless you are provided with one) and build a good set of resources to refer to. Build flexibility into your diary, as additional requests and deadlines can arise unexpectedly. - Keep learning
Maintain your clinical knowledge, keep up your clinical practice, and invest in CPD, training and mentoring. Being an experienced clinician doesn't automatically make you an experienced expert witness – there is a separate skill set to develop and at times it may feel like you are a student again! - Find the right support
You don't have to work everything out alone. A supportive expert witness company, experienced colleagues and good administrative support can make a huge difference, particularly when you're starting out. Every Maggie Sargent and Associates expert witness is allocated a mentor when they are onboarded, to talk through your instructions, your assessment and get as much support as you need to produce a great report, and to maintain your sanity! - Protect your independence
Always remember that your duty is to the court. Be honest, objective and evidence-based, and have the confidence to stand by your professional opinion. - Develop resilience and be patient
Your opinions may be challenged, and building a regular flow of work takes time. Learn from experience, remain professional and don't be disheartened if things don't happen overnight.
Final thoughts
Becoming an expert witness is a learning process. You won't know everything straight away, and that's absolutely fine.
If you're considering becoming an expert witness, my advice is simple: do your research, find a supportive company, know your area of expertise and give yourself time to learn. Ask questions, make use of CPD opportunities and learn from those around you.
Most importantly, remember that being an expert witness is a responsibility. Your independence, clinical knowledge and professional integrity are what make your contribution valuable.
For me, one of the most rewarding aspects is being able to use my clinical experience in a different way, looking at the bigger picture and helping to make sense of what someone may need following a life-changing injury.
It might feel daunting at times, but it’s also interesting, challenging and worthwhile.
And if you enjoy pulling together the pieces of a complex clinical puzzle, you might just find that expert witness work is right up your street!
I hope this series of articles has helped you to better understand the role of an expert witness, what's involved and whether it might be something you'd like to pursue. If you're ready to take the plunge, or simply want to find out a little more, get in touch with Maggie Sargent & Associates. They're a great place to start and can talk you through the opportunities available.
Email: office@maggiesargent.co.uk
Telephone: 01608 682500
Website: https://www.maggiesargent.co.uk
