So, You Want to Become an Expert Witness?

If you’re a therapist or case manager, you might have considered becoming an expert witness.
I’m a busy case manager and treating occupational therapist, but expert witness work is one of my most enjoyable roles.
As an expert witness you will be gathering evidence from different sources, considering the claimant’s circumstances, reviewing clinical information and bringing everything together to formulate an opinion and make recommendations.
Hopefully, those recommendations will help the person access the rehabilitation, care and support they need to improve their quality of life and, where possible, move that person closer towards the position they were in before their injuries.
You might never see those recommendations put into practice. You might never find out how that person gets on. But your work will play an important part in establishing their rehabilitation programmes and future support.
Of course, there are challenges. It can be demanding and your opinion will be scrutinised. You’ll need a thick skin, the ability to think critically and analytically, confidence in your clinical reasoning and the willingness to keep learning.
But if you enjoy problem-solving, analysing information and explaining your clinical opinion, it can be a hugely rewarding area of practice.
Before you jump in, there are a few things worth knowing.
Don’t expect to be an ‘expert’ expert right away
You might be highly experienced in your clinical field, with years of experience under your belt. That’s a fantastic foundation, but being an expert witness is a skill in its own right.
There are new processes to learn, unfamiliar terminology to get your head around and a different way of approaching your work.
Be prepared to learn, ask questions and accept that you won’t know everything from day one. It’s an ongoing learning curve, and that’s absolutely fine!
Know your expertise, and stick to it
When you’re starting out, it can be tempting to say yes to every case that comes your way. After all, you want to build your experience and get your name out there.
But please resist this temptation!
Only accept instructions where you have the appropriate clinical knowledge, skills and experience to provide a properly supported opinion. Be clear about what falls within your expertise and, just as importantly, what doesn’t.
Courts take an expert’s responsibilities seriously, and experts can be criticised by judges for straying beyond their areas of expertise.
It’s far better to turn down a case that isn’t right for you than to accept work you aren’t confident you can undertake competently. Knowing your limitations is a strength, not a weakness.
Don’t go it alone
Having the right support around you makes a huge difference.
You’ll need guidance on the processes, help with the practicalities, opportunities to develop your skills and someone you can turn to when you have a question. Because, believe me, there will be questions!
I’d highly recommend researching the expert witness companies out there and finding one that fits your needs and working style. Look for a company that offers good administrative support, mentoring and regular continuing professional development (CPD). I have to give a special mention here to Maggie Sargent & Associates, who are brilliant at supporting their experts and providing fantastic CPD opportunities.
Expert witness work can sometimes feel like a lonely world, so having people around you who understand the challenges is invaluable.
Keep up your clinical practice
Expert witness work can be a very rewarding and enjoyable role, but don’t fill your diary with expert witness work alone. Maintaining your clinical practice is essential. Your expert opinion needs to be grounded in appropriate, current clinical knowledge and experience.
For those of us combining expert witness work with therapy or case management, balancing the two can work really well, but it helps to be realistic about your capacity. Remember that urgent requests can arise unexpectedly, so try to avoid filling every available hour of your working week.
Above all, remain independent
If there’s one thing I want you to take away from this, it’s this.
Your overriding duty as an expert witness is to the court, not to the claimant and not to the solicitors instructing you. Your role is to provide an independent, objective opinion based on your expertise and the evidence available to you.
You are not there to advocate for one side or produce the answer someone wants to hear. Sometimes your findings will support a claimant’s case, sometimes they won’t. Your responsibility is to be honest, balanced and clear about your reasoning, including any limitations or uncertainties.
There will be times when your opinion is challenged. There may even be times when you realise you’ve got something wrong. We’re all human, and being a good expert means being willing to acknowledge mistakes and reconsider your position when the evidence warrants it.
Having a supportive admin team, a good relationship with your instructing solicitors and confidence in your own clinical knowledge can make these situations much easier to navigate.
Be prepared to stand your ground when necessary, but always do so professionally.
Next up in this series: what does the expert witness process actually involve?
